~Mountain -jan 03 maybe. The venue was a half-full dinner theatre in the asshair bottom woods of snowy Connecticut. I was one of a handfull of individuals under the age of 45. The tour was sponsored by VH1, for Chrissake. Despite these minor setbacks, the show was awesome. Leslie West has continued to grow as a singer and guitarist through the years. Very few people can tear through an epic blues rock composition (I believe certain genre confused hippies used to call it “fusion”) like him. Their only song to make it to the radio and mass consciousness was “Mississippi Queen” (Recently covered by Ozzy Osbourne, ensuring it’s place in the annals of history). While that was an essential single of the classic rock era, their most distinct works were longer compositions like ‘Nantucket Sleighride’. The show provided ample helpings of both sides of the band. Rounding out the trio was original era drummer Corky, who was afforded one badass Zeppelin-esque drum solo showcase. He made up half the band’s personality, entheusiastic and energetic as well as driving the rhythm with considerable power. The recently hired bass player did his job well, but his most memorable characteristic was an affinity for the color purple that permeated his entire fashion ensemble and equipment configuration.
~A Perfect Circle/Year Of The Rabbit opening – November 2003 – Providence Performing Arts Center
This is what I consider to be my first real show. First, the venue was one of the best I’ve ever been in. It’s an entirely seated theatre meant for plays and musicals. The acoustics are perfectly tuned, with bass that fills your chest without being overwhelming.
In 2003 I had recently discovered Tool, an essential band in my musical development, one I still appreciate without loving like I used to. By association I was into A Perfect Circle, singer Maynard James Keenan’s other project. APC’s sound is more indebted to the slowly drizzling guitar arpeggios of ‘Disintegration’-era The Cure than Tool’s progressive/pop rock blend. APC’s albums have not aged that well, as my entheusiasm and hunger for more Maynard has long since subsided, but they did write a handfull of great songs.
This show was the ultimate manifestation of their sound, coming after the release of 2nd album ‘Thirteenth Step’. Josh Freese sounded better there than in any other band I’ve heard him in, even NIN (where he suffered from the unfortunate Matt Cameron/Pearl Jam effect of a great drummer not fitting with a great band). His massive and rhythmically intricate playing was the main attraction. Maynard’s Gollum dance was much appreciated, though. Former Smashing Pumpkins guitarist James Iha skulked in the shadows, earning his paycheck. Twiggy rocked it on bass, and like his future NIN touring mate Freese, had much more creative input and personal investment here. I want to say something nice about lead guitarist/main songwriter Billy Howerdel, but he made the unfortunate choice of letting Maynard overshadow him in his own band. This was far from a Martin Gore/David Gahan (of Depeche Mode) healthy songwriter/frontman relationship, this was a dictatorship of opportunity.
“Thinking Of You” was amped up in intensity compared to it’s original studio version, making a great late set highlight. “The Package” featured Maynard’s most dramatic squat thrusting. “Judith”, the lead single from first album ‘Mer De Noms’, engaged more as the set closer than it ever did on it’s own. Not bad for a side project!
Opening band “Year Of The Rabbit”, featuring Ken Andrews of ‘Failure’, sucked. Their opening song was a cover of “I Wanna Be Adored” by The Stone Roses, which was actually quite excellent, perfectly suited to Ken’s vocal drone and opiated moods. What followed, however, was a series of indistinguishable and startlingly boring songs from Ken’s brief and unfortunate attempt at a sellout band, following the dissolution of Failure. Poor Ken. He looked nice in that dark red velvet button up shirt, though. Maynard brought him out onstage to duet for APC’s cover of “The Nurse Who Loved Me”, originally by Failure. Besides it being a weak cover to start with, Ken looked more pissed off than any other human being I’ve ever seen. It could’ve just been a bad coke comedown, but if I was asked (or compelled by the potential for exposure) to sing backing vocals on a vastly inferior cover of one of my own songs with my singer friend who just happens to be roughly 1,000 times as famous as me, I might be a little bit mad too.
~Mountain, again - Toad’s Place, Connecticut – 2004
Same set, same show, worse venue. “Toad’s Place” is a cancer pit. If you find yourself walking down the street, and are overcome with the sudden urge to puke up $20 worth of bar drinks, don’t puke in the gutter. Run in to Toad’s Place. They don’t give a shit. Fuck Connecticut.
~Muse – Lupo’s Heartbreak Hotel, Providence RI – April 2004
I hate these guys now, but at the time I had just downloaded their album “Absolution”, which has a few good songs. I suddenly became aware of the Lupos show, and it was only 9 dollars (Sponsored by the WBRU “Cheap Date” concert series, hilarious for a band that filled stadiums in the UK. How much payola does it take to become a Cheap Date, I wonder?), so I figured why the hell not. Their live show had a good reputation, too. However, “Absolution” wasn’t even out in the USA yet, due to genius major label marketing techniques. Hence, the venue was half full, with a crowd that must have all downloaded the new album instead of waiting for the privilege of paying for it in a US store. The band was at least well known enough to have about 10-15 kids jumping up and down up front during the faster paced songs, though. I found it hard to believe that even that minor amount of enthusiasm for the band was possible, leaving me dumbfounded when they exploded in popularity worldwide in 2006.
I can understand how the band might have been a little bummed to be playing to a fraction of the stadium crowd that they knew in their hearts they deserved. This show is all I have to go on, though. When I hear people talking about Muse’s amazing, earth shattering, larger than life, bigger than friggin Queen live esperience, I have no earthly idea what the fuck they are talking about. I saw a band competently and consistently sleepwalk through a set that was 2/3 boring midtempo ballads and 1/3 mildly engaging up tempo wailing rockers. At every opportunity, they sacrificed performance and instead used technology to recreate the layers of the studio performance. Hire a rhythm guitarist if you want two guitars at once on most of the songs, buddy. Matt Bellamy is a deft manipulator of pedals and effects, but the overall effect was still something like a band playing to a backing track. For the last song, standout single “Stockholm Syndrome”, they had white balloons drop on the crowd. Friggin’ balloons, can you believe that? Live experience of the MILLENIUM!
~Sonic Youth – April 2004 – Lupos
If I remember correctly, this show was less than a month after the Muse show, at the same venue. It proved to be an excellent way to wash the taste of that crap out of my mouth.
Even approaching their mid-40s (that seemed really old to me at the time, I didn’t know many bands yet that still made good album after hitting 40), Sonic Youth put on a live show as vital and explorative as ever. The setlist was overstuffed with riches, from the best songs on ‘Sister’ to lesser known choices from ‘Washing Machine’ and ‘Trash’. The recent material from “comeback” efforts ‘Sonic Nurse’ and ‘Murray Street’ held their own, but mainly due to the instrumental work. The band’s best songwriting and hooks remain in the Sister/Daydream Nation/Goo/Dirty era, which was very well represented without over-relying on ‘Daydream Nation’, but a good 10 minute feedback freakout makes anything go down easy.
The crowd was mostly 30-ish former Gen-Xers turned yuppies, and young hipster couples in training just beginning to learn how to find a way to use their cellphone for the entire show (Ah, 2004, so distant now…texting was a luxury then, not an essential bodily function). It wasn’t as distracting as having a shirtless brodude beer-singing in your ear the entire show though, so I’ll give this crowd a pass.
~Sparta, opening for Incubus – The Friggin’ Dunkin Donuts Center, Providence RI – July 2004
I was willing to pay Incubus prices for 40 minutes of Sparta. At The Drive-In was still my favorite band, and just seeing 3 of their former members on stage would be enough to get me in the door. Sparta was a great band in their own right (I say “was”, unfortunately, due to their dissapointing 3rd and final album in 2006), though. Their 40 minute set had me hooked from the first note, delivering perfect renditions of 4-5 songs from 2004′s ‘Porcelain’, and debut single “Cut Your Ribbon” from ‘Wiretap Scars’. The band’s style was a continuation of the post-Fugazi punk strains that ran through ATDI, but grew into a more ambitious and intense pop/rock mode once Jim Ward has his own ship to steer. “While Oceania Sleeps” is the best example of this affecting mix of plaintive reflection and sing-along wailing.
Incubus…yeah, they were Incubus. They’re an instrumentally talented bunch of guys with good intentions, who manage to write a catchy song once in a while, in between the pandering bland bullshit. They peaked early on with the Red Hot Chili Peppers meets Faith No More meets Korn amalgamation ‘Science’ in 1998. We got one song from that album, and a whole bunch of other stuff that’s best forgotten.
In addition, they blessed us with a moronic 20 minute bongo jam, and closed with “Black Hole Sun”. Unfortunately, they were Incubus, and not fucking Soundgarden. Hell, they might as well have just played Foo Fighters songs for the whole set, no one would have cared.
~The Roots and 311 – Tweeter/Verizon Ampitheatre, Mansfield MA – July 2004
This seemed like a good idea at the time, because my friends were going, and I hadn’t heard 311 in a while, so I didn’t remember how much they sucked. We were also supposed to see the 1st band on the bill, jam jazz trio Medeski Martin and Wood, but that time was instead spent by our driver filling out an application for a Shaws card so he could get his full discount on the hamburger patties for our parking lot barbecue.
The Roots are an entertaining live band even for someone who barely knows their albums. ?uestlove gets down with impeccable style and sophistication on the drums, and the band is filled out with rock and funk adept musicians. They morph in and out of rock cover band mode throughout the set, even throwing in friggin’ “Iron Man” somewhere in the middle of a medley. Somehow, it all seemed natural. Pretty much the complete opposite of Incubus doing “Black Hole Sun”.
Then, 311 came on. It’s a damn shame when you let your opening band upstage you. I felt embarassed for them when they attempted a scripted bass solo (“Hey P-Nut! BEAT THAT THING!”) that was a complete joke compared to the Roots funky bass solo we had just seen. And, hey, another 20 minute bongo jam! These guys had been doing it a little longer than Incubus, though. They earned their bongo cred back when Incubus was still in middle school.
At one point, the band asked us to yell and cheer for 1 of 2 possible songs they were considering playing. The song with the louder response would win. They said this was supposed to be “practice” for the upcoming 2004 election, a real working example of democracy in action. Then, later, they played the losing song anyways. The irony.
~Pearl Jam – Sovereign Center, Reading PA – October 2004
Reading, what a shithole. To single out one particular place in Pennsylvania as a shithole, it must be a really deep shithole. A nail salon and a pawn shop on every block. Air choked with despair. Heads hung low in defeat. It wasn’t quite Baltimore, but it made Cherry Hill, New Jersey look like San Francisco.
I had just belatedly discovered Pearl Jam, and combined with my 90s nostalgia fetish, I had enough motivation to get somebody to travel 6 hours to see this show (and an 11 hour bus ride back, but that’s another story). The 2003 Pearl Jam live DVD was also one of the best in my collection, so I knew I would be in for something special. I also wanted to see them before they got old and crappy. As of now, they haven’t released a good album since 2000, so you be the judge of that.
This was an in-between albums special tour, so thankfully the set was light on song from 2002′s ‘Riot Act’. It wasn’t one of their better setlists overall, but the larger than life presence of the band and overwhelming positive vibes (god, it sounds like I’m reviewing a Phish show) smoothed over the handfull of mediocre numbers. A few weak tunes in a 3 hour set is about as good as it gets, anyways.
Even after hearing “Alive” 10 billion times on the radio, that song still managed to enthrall me along with the entire audience, as Eddie jigged away along the edge of the stage, with Mike McCready’s extended solo blazing. Pearl Jam is a live band that knows how to take the familiar and make it extraordinary, at least in the moment.
The set list anomolies were “Sad”, from the B-side collection ‘Lost Dogs’, and a tune with guest Tim Robbins. It sucked. Tim Robbins, you’re a great actor, but you can’t hang with Pearl Jam. Neil Young can hang with Pearl Jam. You’re just a wannabe.
…and that concluded Part One of this feature. Only 22 more shows to go!